Context in grading

This is another grading-related post, but it's also about context, which is one of my favourite terms.

I believe context is extremely important. Understanding context is what keeps humans from being machines. I think at least eighty percent of interpersonal conflict comes from disregarding or misunderstanding the context. Probably I will say something on this later.

But this post will be on context when grading. I don't have that much to say on the topic, but I needed to point out that when you grade exams, the ultimate goal is to assess whether the student has grasped the curriculum or not.

A person who is bureaucratic by nature (i.e. has a tendency to ignore context) will simply look at whether the student has written down the correct answer (in the natural sciences, that is). If it's not on the paper, it is irrelevant for the grading process.

And by doing so, the bureaucrat has failed to accomplish the goal of grading - namely to assess the student's grasp of the curriculum.

That is because what is written is not the only source of information available to the grader. Being a human, the grader also has access to the context of what is written.

As an example: If a student, during an explanation of some kind, uses the wrong word for a key term, the bureaucrat will automatically see that as an error. Don't get me wrong - it might be an error, but only insofar as it demonstrates a lack of understanding by the student. How to we ascertain this? By examining the context. If a student otherwise clearly shows what he/she is talking about, demonstrating an excellent command of the subject matter, then this error in wording shouldn't be taken as a symptom of lack of understanding, but simply as a symptom of momentary forgetfulness. However, if, along with this error, the student writes an explanation which shows that he/she has just been memorizing the curriculum, not really understanding what is going on, the error can be taken as a symptom of lack of understanding. In other words, the context determines whether this error should be penalized or not!

More on context later.